I’m in no mood to ‘celebrate’ America. Our country is broken and needs repair | Jamil Smith
The Guardian – US News
theguardian.com
Summary
America at 250 is not a finished monument, but a structure still under repair T o call this Saturday the nation’s 250th birthday is to indulge a comfortable fiction. 1776 was a declaration, not a birth certificate – and the founders wrote its claims of human equality while this nation enslaved human beings. In the final days before 4 July, the US supreme court gave the country a diagnosis of itself. It preserved one of the country’s greatest repairs – birthright citizenship under the 14th amendment – while loosening a guardrail against corruption and weakening another promise of equal protection. The president tried, by executive order, to read the children of undocumented and temporary residents out of the 14th amendment. Birthright citizenship is proof that the founding promise did not preserve itself; it had to be rebuilt into the constitution after the country’s own highest court exposed the lie beneath the celebration. Within hours, the president called the ruling “too bad for our Country” and told Congress to “start TODAY” on ending birthright citizenship, insisting no amendment was needed. That is not how the constitution works – ordinary legislation cannot rewrite a constitutional guarantee. But he is reaching for a door a sixth justice left ajar: Brett Kavanaugh wrote that Congress could carve out exceptions by statute. As it protected citizenship, the court took down a guardrail meant to keep representation from becoming a market. Days earlier, Congress passed a rare bipartisan housing bill to make homes easier to build and afford.
From the source
America at 250 is not a finished monument, but a structure still under repair To call this Saturday the nation’s 250th birthday is to indulge a comfortable fiction. 1776 was a declaration, not a birth certificate – and the founders wrote its claims of human equality while this nation enslaved human beings. A truer account of American freedom runs through 1619 and Juneteenth , when Americans forced the country, at last, to begin making its promises answerable to reality. So I’m not in the mood to celebrate “America 250”, and I’m not alone. The affection is thin this summer: the Pew Research Center found that 69% of Americans were dissatisfied with the country’s direction early this year. That is not ingratitude. Sometimes a sour mood is simply clear vision. Jamil Smith is a Guardian US columnist Continue reading...
Read the full article
Published by The Guardian – US News on theguardian.com


